Coastal Group Chair Steve Willis wrote the following letter to the Secretary of the Army about the Savannah Harbor Deepening
John M. McHugh
Secretary of the Army
101 Army Pentagon
Washington, DC 20310-0101
Sir,
The USA is rapidly moving towards one of the most crippling
self-inflicted wounds it has ever suffered, and the U.S. Army Corps of
Engineers (COE) is chiefly responsible for this imminent debacle.
I am speaking of the scheme to deepen the Port of Savannah
Channel to 47 feet in order to accommodate the super-sized container ships
which will call on East Coast ports more frequently after the Panama Canal
deepening is completed (originally scheduled for 2014, now 2015). It is likely that the on-going session of the
U.S. Congress will provide funding for the radical COE-recommended deepening of
the Port of Savannah.
The U.S. is the only major global commercial power with no
national port strategy. The U.S. now
considers and approves harbor expansion and deepening proposals solely on when
the COE receives requests, and when the COE completes its “studies.” It is as if the COE’s paperwork process is
far more important than the realities of the world and commerce, or the true
interests of the U.S. To proceed with
the expansion and deep-dredging of the Port of Savannah without due
consideration of America’s strategic transportation requirements and options
seems to be absolutely unjustifiable.
There is no port in the USA (or the world, for that matter),
less suitable for this purpose than the Port of Savannah. If the Savannah channel is deepened, it will
result in an extended narrow 38 mile long, winding, silt-prone, dangerous
passageway. The Georgia Coast also has the largest, most forceful tides on the
Atlantic coast south of Fundy Bay. The
ships that this deepened channel is meant to accommodate are longer than the
largest aircraft carriers. This foolish
scheme is much like relocating the Norfolk Navy Base from the deep water at the
mouth of the Chesapeake to Savannah.
Clearly, this project is far more political than practical, and will
deeply undermine America’s interests.
The combined Federal and State investments in this project
(note that the Port of Savannah is a Georgia State Authority, and therefore ALL
of its funds are state funds), if expended, will amount to well over a billion
dollars. This project will also, by the
COE’s own estimates, produce almost $300,000,000 in environmental damage.
South Carolinians opposed to the Savannah Harbor Deepening have
accurately noted that the COE analysis was conducted as if South Carolina did
not exist. Far worse, in my opinion, is
the COE recommendations’ apparent obliviousness to the current state of global
maritime commerce, or any knowledge of proven, successful national port
strategies anywhere in the world.
The COE has failed to consider these damning facts:
· Site Selection – Nowhere in the world is there
now a single Savannah-like port situated far up a single, narrow river channel
being used to host super-sized container vessels, nor are any such ports under
consideration to be developed in the future.
Two of the largest ports in the world, Rotterdam and
Shanghai, were situated much like Savannah, deep inland, with silt-prone
rivers. Recognizing the futility of
perpetual dredging to accommodate ever-larger container ships, the EEU and
China determined to build new, nearby, ocean ports. Rotterdam developed the Europort at the mouth
of the Nieuwe Waterweg River/Canal, and Shanghai built its new deep-water
Yangshan Port on a nearby ocean island, connected to the mainland by a 20 mile
long bridge. Today Rotterdam is the
largest port in Europe, and Shanghai is the largest container port in the
world.
·
Depth – even at 47 feet, the Port of Savannah
will still be tidally constrained for the biggest ships already in service;
they require 50+ foot channels.
· Only Hub Ports Worldwide – throughout the world
only ports capable of being used as “hubs” have been developed to host
supersized ships.
Hub ports are necessary for
hosting supersized ships because they can be accessed quickly and safely by many
ships of varying sizes. Savannah’s single, narrow channel prohibits
this. Much like large commercial
aircraft, such as Boeing 747s, the super-sized ships must operate at near
capacity in order to be economically viable.
Advantages of scale diminish quickly if ships operate at partial load. By enabling easy access for many sizes of
ships, full loads for the largest ships can be assembled and dispersed by
smaller ships, which can economically carry smaller loads. All ships calling on a hub port can sail at
near capacity, greatly boosting productivity.
Savannah’s narrow channel virtually prohibits its use as a hub
port. The necessary work of assembling
and dispersing container loads in Savannah must forever be by rail or
truck. The much more economical and environmentally
advantageous use of smaller ships, such as “short sea shipping,” to link up
with the super-sized ships is unsuitable for Savannah.
·
Unrealistic Dredging Plans -- no other nation or
region has considered deep-dredging for nearly so many deep water ports as the COE
envisions being dredged in the U.S.
The COE has a laundry list of 17
U.S. ports for deep-dredging under review, in addition to the seven already
deepened or currently being deep-dredged. This radical discontinuity can best be
explained, I believe, by the tried and true Department of Defense strategy of
spreading its spending as far and wide throughout the states as possible. This buys political support not only for COE
Civil Works, but for all DOD projects and policy initiatives. Making deals and compromises is certainly
more often than not essential to effective policy advocacy in Washington, but
in this case, with the future of American global competitiveness in jeopardy,
an unwillingness to abandon engrained bureaucratic tendencies seems
unpatriotic, or worse.
Europe – according to the Economist magazine, all of Europe
anticipates only four to five ports will be needed to accommodate the largest
container ships.
China – China, which moves more container boxes each day than
the rest of the world combined, has developed only eight ports to accommodate
the super-sized ships. All of these
eight ports are situated directly on the ocean, and are hub ports.
U.S. West Coast – for decades the West Coast has very
successfully hosted super-sized ships which were unable to transit the Panama
Canal. Four ports, (Spokane, Oakland and
Los Angeles-Long Beach (which is physically one, co-located port) have an
excellent record for meeting the big ships’ needs. In fact, the port of LA/Long Beach handles
about 40% of all U.S. maritime container traffic.
Unfortunately, these are not the matters which should most
concern a responsible decision maker.
The most damaging prospect is that this ill-placed Savannah port will be
an obstacle and impediment for U.S. maritime commerce for many decades to come. Once dug, and once the environmental impacts
become highly visible and irreversible, the Port of Savannah will never be
undug. Once dug, there will be no way to
reverse this debacle.
Savannah’s unsuitability, which is obvious to interested and
informed people now, will become apparent to all soon after Savannah begins
hosting fully loaded super-sized container ships. Unfortunately, this predictable Savannah
Port failure will sharply curtail enthusiasm for deep dredging of other much
more suitable nearby ports, such as Charleston and Jacksonville, as well as the
proposed new Port of Jasper.
Certainly
the predictable difficulties which will be experienced by super-sized ships
attempting to navigate the long, winding, Savannah channel, and the expected dire
environmental impacts (which routinely far exceed COE projections on most of
their projects) will be dismal. Still,
the most insuperable consequence will be the log-jam blocking of the much more
desirable port options in the Southeastern region. Competitive ports will not be funded in an
era of fiscal constraint, especially with the grim example of Savannah looking
decision makers in the face. If additional nearby ports are dredged, they
will be forced to compete with an operating Savannah mega port, which will create
overcapacity, and sharply reduce their economic desirability and feasibility. Within a space of only a hundred miles or so
multiple overlapping and interlocking vast onshore transportation
infrastructures will be required. Not
only will this be painfully expensive, but the spaghetti-like entanglement of
taxpayer-funded rail and road systems will sharply diminish the Southeast’s
competiveness rather than enhance it.
There is also the sop which has been proposed by deceitful
Georgia plenipotentiaries to build a new port on the Savannah Channel in Jasper
County on the South Carolina side of the river.
This is a rather transparent ruse is intended to dampen South Carolina’s
opposition to the deepening of the Savannah Channel seven miles or more upstream
past the Jasper site to the main Port of Savannah port facilities. Of course, the Jasper port would block the
channel, and make access to the main Port of Savannah facilities close to impossible. The Jasper site would be far better sited
than the Port of Savannah, but it will never be built if the channel is
deepened past the proposed Jasper site.
It is entirely possible that America’s Southeastern Atlantic
deep water port needs can best be met by developing Miami and Norfolk/Hampton
Roads as hub ports. Not only, as the COE
has repeatedly noted, would Charleston, Savannah and Jacksonville continue to
grow at about the same rate due to local direct shipping demands, these ports
would boom due to the much more efficient hub-spoke interconnections to global
markets through international hubs – exactly like state and regional airports
prosper because of their international linkage through international airport hubs.
If a competent and
objective analysis proved that a deep-water port were needed within the ocean
front between Newport News and Miami, either Charleston, Jasper, Savannah, or
Jacksonville, or some fresh site (an alternative Rotterdam and Shanghai have
shown to have great potential) should be selected and developed. It is virtually certain Savannah would be the
very least likely of these candidates to be selected.
What is certain is that no thoughtful person would recommend
developing more than one deep water port to host super-sized container ships
along the 200 mile coastline from Jacksonville to Charleston, much less four,
as the COE seems to advocate.
It is extremely prudent
to urge you to demand better from your subordinates. Remember,
America’s ports are our doorways to the world; virtually all of North America’s
global manufacturing commerce moves in an out of its ports. Can any informed American countenance COE’s failure
to understand world maritime commerce, to develop a credible strategic port
plan integrated with onshore infrastructure requirements, or COE’s championing
of
a disaster-in-the-making like the reengineering of the river Port of Savannah
to host aircraft-carrier-sized container ships?
I urge you to inform Congress that a credible analysis of our
Nation’s best port and supporting infrastructure and strategic options must be
completed before throwing a monkey wrench like the deep-dredging of the Port of
Savannah into the middle of America’s East Coast transportation and
manufacturing systems.
America’s future economic global welfare and strategic strength
depends on it.
In our common interest,
Steve Willis,
Savannah, Georgia